A week ago, I talked to one of the writers who departed SDSU. He told me that he didn't see any solution to the impasse, that he was looking for other work, that he didn't think all or most of the writers would ever work under an IATSE/839 contract.
This is a fustercluck of Sony's own making. A decade ago, the company didn't have a problem with putting Dilbert writers into a company named Appleton that wasn't covered by an 839 contract, the boys and girls just went ahead and did it.
At the time, I drove to Culver City to complain about the move. The execs in Sony Labor Relations looked it at me as if I'd stepped out of an interstellar craft with a dead space alien under one arm.
And a couple of months later, the WGAw swooped in and organized Appleton.
So here we are, ten years further on, and Sony in its brilliance is now screwing the proverbial doggie yet again. From what I've gleaned from various sources, the following took place:
1) Animated show based on live-action Australiam sitcom Shut Up, Sit Down is set up at Sony-Adelaide. Writing staff that's hired is 80-100% WGA sitcom writers.
2) Writers' agents told by Sony the production is under an 839 contract. This isn't acceptable to writers. Big exec at Sony Television says "Not to worry, we can make it a WGA show." Reassured, the writers soldier on.
3) Other execs at Sony say: "Uh, no we can't make it a WGA show." Writers walk.
The WGA maintains that it represents all writers of prime-time animation. I agree, with the proviso: "Except when the WGA doesn't."
We are now at a point where the show could very well be permanently shut down. If that happens, there will be no writers working (14 jobs). There will also be no designers or board artists or animation directors working (35-45 jobs).
You can probably deduce why I'm just a teensy bit ticked off about all of this. See, my job as an IATSE rep is to protect traditional IATSE jurisdiction, but my job is also to aid and abet the creation of as many animation jobs as possible under TAG 839 contracts. Because Sony couldn't figure out how to cobble a crew together that would do the work, fourteen writer jobs look like they're going down, and taking 40 or so other jobs along with them.
Craig Mazin at the Artful Writer has a take similar to mine:
According to one of the writers on the show, when the staff was being put together, the writers heard that the show was going to be IATSE and asked that the show instead be WGA. The creative execs didn’t think that would be a problem…if the show got picked up they’d be able to figure that out.
I propose that if this recounting is true, then the creative execs either lied or simply didn’t understand how the world of labor-management works.
Flash foward…and Sony business affairs informs all of the writers involved that no, the show is going to be IATSE, all Sony Adelaide shows are IATSE, and that’s it, end of story, period, full stop.
So the writers walked.
And so we sit in the middle of a conundrum.
Sadly, Sony can't unshit the bed, because if it moves Sit Down, Shut Up writers to another company now, the IATSE will likely litigate.
The writers are off looking for other jobs/ working on other jobs. None of them -- from what I know -- will be coming back without a WGA contract.
And if Sit Down, Shut Up ends up going the way of the Titanic, then several dozen animation artists will not be working.
Neat. Not.